Wednesday 21 September 2022

Climbing with Mulan

Mulan is on school exam study break at the moment, so of course we all forgot about study and went climbing today.

(Actually, Mulan had all her exams early, so she's now got a short holiday until next week.)

And Mulan got her first ever green climb!!!

A few months ago we agreed that if (and when) Mulan gets a green we'd have a special takeaway dinner together.  So the girls had Subway and Fanta tonight.

And then it was time for photos.

Here's Miya cutting loose with a one-handed dyno:

And here's Mulan showing off her splits.  (Pity we forgot our good camera -- we had to use my phone, which has a scratch that looks like a mark on Mulan's face.)

Friday 16 September 2022

Update on reading the Bible

I've slowed down with reading the Bible.

The other day I said I had read Genesis.  I've now finished the books of Exodus and Leviticus, as well as Numbers up to chapter 19.

Unfortunately I've now caught up with Hemant Mehta's reading and commentary, so from now on I can only read a chapter a week.

According to Wikipedia there are 1189 chapters in the Bible.  I've read 136 chapters, which means there are another 1053 chapters to go.  At a chapter a week that'll be another 20 1/4 years; I'll be retired before I get to the end!

As a churched child I was pretty familiar with the stories in these books, repeatedly reading various sections dotted throughout.  But up until now I'd never read all these books completely and continuously, and that gives a very different feel.

Reading continuously gives a better sense of the percentage of words spent on various topics, and hence the priorities.  And genuinely equally reading each chapter -- not merely skimming over the boring bits and focusing on the well-known bits -- has been really important for this.

I feel that this has allowed me to get a much better sense of the character of God in these books.  Not only can we often read directly what God says and does, but we can also infer values by looking at what is included, the amount it is included, and what is excluded.

What stands out for me is the amount of words spent detailing both the rituals for worshipping God and the various penalties and punishments for failing to correctly adhere to those rituals.  By far, the focus for human right action is on how to interact correctly with God.  Comparatively speaking, there is very little on how humans should interact with each other or their environment, except inasmuch as it affects God.

The impression given is that the God of these books doesn't care much about people, as people.  He is not so interested in their feelings, their loves, their lives, their interests, their relationships, their families, their wellbeing, and whatever is personally important to them.  He cares even less about non-human animals.

The character of God, as portrayed in these books so far, is self-absorbed, insecure, quick to anger at perceived insults against himself, and with a tendency to lash out with violence when angry.  This violence is often lethal, with both spontaneous and pre-meditated killing and torture of individuals and groups of people.  Often his victims had absolutely nothing to do with the supposed wrong and were merely innocent bystanders.  A significant aspect of what appeases him is the torture and killing of animals, the burning of their flesh (and its smell) and the splashing of their blood.

In other words, the God of these books comes across to me as morally repugnant.  Of all the characters portrayed in the Bible so far, God easily stands out as morally the worst, to the point that if we were to call anyone evil it would be him.  If such a being existed in reality I'd be opposed to him.

What I would like for Christians to do is, when reading the Bible, look at what it says God does, and imagine how you would feel if a human did those exact same things.  Can you honestly say that what God does in the Bible is good and just and right?  Is the God of the Bible really worthy of worship?

(Of course, the Bible makes much more sense if it's seen as a collection of different texts written over many hundreds of years by many different people and compiled and edited by many others.  Matt Baker at UsefulCharts has some excellent videos on when the various parts of the Bible were written and compiled, including this summary chart.)

UPDATE 7/11/2022: Matt Baker has just uploaded a combined YouTube video of the earlier multi-part series on when the various parts of the Bible were written.  Well worth watching.)

Tuesday 13 September 2022

Dance show

We're counting down the days to Mulan and Miya's dance show this Saturday 17th.

This is Classical Collab's performance of Reframe, which they've been rehearsing for the past several weeks.

They've uploaded a few promo videos to their YouTube channel, including some teasers of what Mulan and Miya are doing.



Tickets are available here.

Monday 12 September 2022

Wednesday 7 September 2022

Reading the Bible

I'm not sure if, for blog consistency sake, I should name this post Book review: Genesis.  But I'm going with the more clickbaity/shocking one for the family.

Yep, I'm reading the Bible.

I should qualify that.  I've just finished Genesis, the first of 66 (give or take, depending on your version) books of the Bible, so there's still a way to go.

I think I last read Genesis in full over 30 years ago, so there's a lot I didn't remember.  I'm now continuing on with Exodus.

I should qualify that some more.  I'm actually listening to someone else read aloud the Bible, while I follow along to the text.

And some more qualification: This person reads the text then provides a commentary on it, all in a handy YouTube series, one Bible chapter per video.

So, averaging something like 11 minutes per video-chapter, you can do the maths for how many hours I've already spent listening to 50-chapter Genesis.

Occasionally Mulan or Miya sit with me too, and Mulan especially enjoys it.

On to my thoughts:

The commentator is Hemant Mehta, whose YouTube channel is called Friendly Atheist.  This Bible series is called Everything Wrong with Genesis in the Bible.  So, yeah, with names like that we're not likely to be glossing over the Biblical oddities.

But Hemant's friendly and entertaining, and somehow even the long Bible family tree name lists are not too boring with him.

Hemant approaches the Bible as a person of today, raising questions that most of us would likely have when reading the Bible.  As Mulan said, he points out the obvious things.  Eg:

  • Internal self-contradictions.  Sometimes the Bible contradicts itself, and it's impossible for both passages to be true at the same time.  Often this is to do with (a) how certain events are said to have happened, (b) family relationships, (c) ages of people, (d) numbers of things.  Hemant usefully points out where the section we're reading contradicts another section of the Bible.

  • Contradictions with current best-evidence science.  Sometimes events that the Bible describes cannot possibly have really happened according to current best scientific evidence.

  • Morality.  Characters in the Bible frequently do some pretty bad stuff.  God is one of the worst offenders.  There's plenty of genocide, rape, murder, slavery and incest.  And then there's the soap-opera-worthy nasty family dynamics.  The sexist male domination is stand-out bad, too.

  • Storytelling.  As Hemant says, the Bible could have used an editor.  There are issues of event ordering, repetition, missed information, unnecessary information, etc.

  • And then simply weird stuff.  Hemant's tone is perfect for reacting to the absurdities.

The main weakness with Hemant's commentary, as I see it, is that he doesn't spend much time detailing how and why the cultures of the day(s) saw things differently, and how that influenced their behaviours.  Sometimes he's a little too quick to point out the oddities, without explaining why the people of the day thought those oddities made sense within their culture.  From an intercultural awareness perspective there could be a little more cultural context and sympathy, before jumping to the humour/criticism.  (Though to be fair to Hemant, his point, as he says at the beginning of the series, is to show how it makes no sense to take the Bible literally, as the inerrant word of God.  He is not doing cultural studies.)

But overall, reading along with Hemant is a great way to read the Bible.  For non-Christians it's an enjoyable intro into something that everyone should be familiar with.  For Christians it's worth stepping back to get a fresh perspective.  And for ex-Christians like myself, it's a comfortable back-to; rehearing the familiar childhood stories while also recalling why it was all best left in childhood.  Highly recommended.  Here's the start of the series: